Even after 95 years, customers still look for their favorite caramels and chocolates in the same spot in the same glass cases they've always been in at Niemann's Candies.
Of course, those vintage cases are displayed four miles west of where they started in 1919, near the old Colonial Theatre, at N. 13th and W. Vliet streets in Milwaukee.
"If there's any 90-plus-year-olds out there, they might remember," joked Jim Niemann, owner and third generation candy-maker.
That initial move isn't the only stop the shop made before settling on Harwood Avenue.
An enlarged post card is all that's left of those early days. But around 1927, back when the Tosa band shell first swelled with music and the street car still turned around at the end of the block, founder Frederick Niemann moved his store to Wauwatosa Avenue.
"There was nothing there," said Jim Niemann, who took over the business, also known as Niemann's Chocolate Shop, in 1986. "And they really started as a jack of all trades. They did candies, ice cream. They had hot dogs and all kinds of roast beef sandwiches, basically, to serve the people who went to the band concerts."
The shop later moved to Underwood Avenue, where gawkers gathered around the window to witness the wonders of Niemann's new automated ice cream machine.
"It wasn't a thing of beauty. But they were proud of it and it was an attraction, so they put it in the window," Niemann said.
It's been 44 years since the store moved to Harwood Avenue, where Niemann and company still make ice cream on-site, albeit at the back of the shop. And it's been 28 years since Niemann bought that shop from his parents, Emily and William Niemann.
Grandfather and father have both since passed. But Niemann said their method of making candy by hand still lives on. And while Niemann still likes to get his hand sticky, making traditional toffees and chocolates by the box, he really enjoys running the business, expanding into specialties like candy molds for the Zoological Society of Milwaukee and selling chocolate-covered cranberries at the Wisconsin State Fair – a bigger challenge than it might seem.
"That's been a huge hit, but it caused a lot of stress," Niemann said. "We had to have thousands and thousands of these things, and we had to retool our shop a bit and figure out how to put cranberries on astick. The first year, we could not keep up with demand. We had everybody in the family working day and night. That's what keeps us going."
JUST THE FACTS
Business: Niemann's Candies, 7475 Harwood Ave.
Phone: (414) 774-4940
Owner: Jim Niemann
Type of business: candy shop
Pearls of wisdom: "We had everybody in the family working day and night. That's what keeps
Your link to the biggest stories in the suburbs delivered Thursday mornings.
Enter your e-mail address above and click "Sign Up Now!" to begin receiving your e-mail newsletter Get the Newsletter!
- Longfellow hosting Wauwatosa's Memorial Day ceremony Monday
- Wauwatosa Police Report: May 10-16 (1)
- Choice school, dry cleaning issues held for more discussion in Wauwatosa
- Ask Now: Why are there so many traffic lights on Highway 100? (2)
- Wauwatosa to take extra step vetting St. Camillus proposal for tallest building in city
- Yellow Wood will bring high-quality outdoors gear to Whitefish Bay
- Medical College plans expansion with demolition of building on Mayfair Road
- Wauwatosa approves conceptual design for pocket park on North Avenue (8)
- Wauwatosa School Board approves raises for teachers, administrators and staff
- Tosa Tonight releases lineup for summer concert series